The Illinois Policy Institute and the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research have launched a “pension calculator” that purports to show how much money private sector workers would need to save toward retirement in order to match government pensions.
The link here takes you to a web page that has a box for calculations on the left side. Questions walk users through a series of decisions about what categories they would work in if they were state employees or lawmakers.
In my own case, I learned that I would need to save about $825,000 to match the lifetime annuity offered to a state worker.
There are some things the website does not factor into the calculations. For instance, a private sector 401(k) is not limited to monthly disbursements. It can be used in part or in whole at its owners discretion.
What the calculator does is assign an average lifespan to the government worker. Females have a longer expected retirement. But if a government worker dies a year after retirement, the pension can stop or be reduced, depending on the situation. A 401(k) remains the property of the retiree’s estate.
Another point that state pensioners make is that they pay into their pension plans at rates of 8 to 12 percent. They have no option to adjust their contribution in the same way 401(k) holders can. It is state lawmakers who underfunded the pension program by skipping or reducing the employer’s matching contribution, workers say.
Figure the legislative pensions on the calculator if you want an eyeopener.


